Private Eye logo
street of shame
Mr Gilberthorpe’s Tory paedo files
Unreliable witness, Issue 1372
anthony gilberthorpe.jpg
MR FIXIT: Anthony Gilberthorpe, who says he was paid to recruit underage rent boys for orgies attended by ministers from Margaret Thatcher’s cabinet
SIR Keith Joseph! Sir Rhodes Boyson! Sir Michael Havers! All senior Tories from the Thatcher era, and every one of them a paedophile – at least according to Anthony Gilberthorpe, billed as the “Tory child abuse whistleblower” by the Sunday Mirror, which has been running a string of sensational exclusives based on his allegations.

Gilberthorpe, a former Gloucestershire county councillor and party activist, says that in 1989 he sent a 40-page dossier to Margaret Thatcher (a friend of his, or so he claims) accusing several of her cabinet ministers of “abusing underage boys at drug-fuelled conference parties”. And he should know, for he was paid to recruit underage rent-boys for the orgies.

Other newspapers, especially the Daily Mail, have eagerly recycled the story. But none has taken the precaution of warning readers that Gilberthorpe – known to his few remaining friends as “Gilby” – is not the most reliable of witnesses.

Phantom engagement
In September 1987, for example, he announced his engagement in the Times to Miss Leah Bergdorf-Hunt, a fashion designer from California. The Gloucester Express reported the news on its front page under the headline “Gilby to Marry”. It quoted Gilberthorpe as saying: "Both our families are delighted… I hope this will explain to a few people about my recent visits to America.” But there was no engagement, and indeed no Miss Bergdorf-Hunt. As revealed in Eye 690, the whole thing was a fantasy.

In 1988 – the year before he claims to have sent Thatcher his dossier – he was awarded almost £50,000 libel damages against the Gloucester Citizen, Daily Mirror and Sun, all of which had reported that he was resigning as a councillor “amid allegations that he is a homosexual, has the killer disease Aids and has obtained £250,000 in cash and property from a disabled old-age pensioner”.

The odd feature of the case was that the local news-agency reporter who had supplied the story identified his source as Gilberthorpe himself. Mark Mitchell told the court that Gilby had phoned him from a London hotel to announce that he was quitting as a councillor because a national newspaper was about to allege that he’d had treatment for Aids at a New York clinic.

Egg on face
Gilberthorpe’s version was that he said he would return to Gloucester that day to answer allegations that he’d acquired £250,000 from a former patient of a nursing home he owned. It was Mitchell who mentioned Aids, asking if he had it – to which Gilby said no. This account was corroborated by his friend Piers Merchant, a Tory MP who had been in Gilberthorpe’s hotel bedroom when he rang the news agency and heard the conversation.

Gilberthorpe never collected his £50,000, however. The three newspapers appealed, and dug out new information which cast serious doubt on the Gilby-Merchant version of events. Gilberthorpe delayed and delayed, and eventually settled before the appeal came to court. The newspapers paid not a penny in damages and contributed only £5,000 to his legal costs – leaving him very much out of pocket and with egg all over his face.

Shopped his friend
And what of Piers Merchant MP, who had so gallantly testified for his chum? In 1997 he and his young mistress, Anna Cox, went to stay for the weekend with Gilberthorpe. Shortly afterwards they were amazed to see quotes from their pillow-talk and photos of them in bed splashed all over the Sunday Mirror. Gilby, it transpired, had fitted out the spare-room with hidden cameras and microphones and shopped his loyal friend to the tabloid for £25,000.

How much the Sunday Mirror has paid him this time is not known. He has no evidence to support his claims about Keith Joseph, Michael Havers et al – but at least they are all conveniently dead and in no fit state to sue.

More top stories in the latest issue:

The Times finally suspends tennis correspondent Neil Harman after the Eye reveals his plagiarism… but he’s not the only flagrant borrower on the staff.

Trinity Mirror has a timely clear-out of staff – some of whose knowledge of historic phone hacking might have proved embarrassing down the line.

How do you shift a foreign corr who’s too expensive to make redundant? Order him back to London and make him pay his own utility bills!

The Telegraph suddenly goes quiet on its call for Russian sanctions. Could a web sponsorship deal with Rossiyskaya Gazeta have anything to do with it?

Defence secretary Michael Fallon and the Telegraph’s Bryony Gordon go into spin mode over the ‘slut’ row… but what’s that in Bryony’s memoir?

Tweeting Rupert Murdoch can’t recall if daughter Elisabeth knows the PM (she does: she introduced the pair of them), while the hacking trial warrants not a word!

Guardian media guru Roy Greenslade applauds an insurrection by Express hacks… but ignores a motion closer to home critical of Grauniad bosses.

Independent hacks complain about bullying by digital editor Christian Broughton – a ‘fucking slavedriver’, they say – but the paper does nothing.

To read all these stories in full, you can buy the latest edition of Private Eye - or subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale:
19th August 2014.
More From This Issue
more »
HP Sauce
Latest stories
more »
HP Sauce
Win a £100 prize
more »
Also Available Online
More From This Issue
Private Eye Issue 1372
private eye Only In The Magazine

WoEbola Virus Spreads to Front Pages Shock… Your Stars with the Amazing David Tredinnick MP… Fifty Shades of May – a Sneak Preview… Commonwealth Games, Day 94… The Book of Benjamin, Chapter 95… Me and My Spoon with Dr Jonathan Miller… Banker ‘Doesn’t Break Law’ Shock… World War III Memorial Issue… Ed Miliband Beside the Seaside, as told to Craig Brown

And also...

- Tennis balls: Game, set & match as the Eye uncovers another plagiarist at the Times
- Knacker’s yard: Cleveland police is a small force… but it has big, big problems
- Al-Qaeda Alert: The blabbermouth peer who blew the gaff on Channel Tunnel security
For all these stories you can buy the magazine or subscribe here and get delivery direct to your home every fortnight.
Next issue on sale: 19th August 2014.

Private Eye Issue 1371