Private Eye logo
hp sauce
One rule for Tories, another for the RMT
Domestic violence, Issue 1373
morning star.jpg
LAST MONTH the Communist Morning Star gave space and prominence to a demand by Women’s Aid that Tory MP David Ruffley must face “strong disciplinary sanction” for assaulting his ex-partner. Short shrift was given to his claim that because the ex-partner had accepted his apology no more needed to be done. As readers were reminded: "Domestic violence is a criminal, not a private matter.”

Well, if it’s committed by a Tory MP, that is. When the alleged perpetrator is a senior trade union official, the Morning Star will discipline any of its hacks who has the temerity to pursue the story. That is what it did to Rory MacKinnon, its Scotland correspondent, who quit last week after three years on the paper.

In March this year MacKinnon was sent to cover a women’s conference in Glasgow organised by the RMT transport union. For months, women he knew in the union had been talking about Caroline Leneghan, an RMT member who had written a blog-post about the violence allegedly inflicted on her by Steve Hedley, the RMT’s assistant general secretary, with whom she was in a relationship until last year. On one occasion, she wrote, he “threw me around by my hair and pinned me to the floor repeatedly punching me in the face”. She published photos taken at the time, showing her horrendously bruised and swollen face.

Finding himself attending an RMT women’s conference – and one at which the RMT was launching its new policy on, er, domestic violence – MacKinnon thought it a good moment to ask if the union’s refusal to hold a proper investigation into the allegations against its assistant general secretary might affect female members’ perception of the union. He put the question at a Q&A session with the union’s national organising co-ordinator Alan Pottage, who declined to answer. Soon afterwards, however, the hack was forcibly ejected from the conference.

‘Gross misconduct’
The next day, Morning Star editor Richard Bagley told MacKinnon he was being suspended while his bosses investigated allegations of “gross misconduct” and “bringing the paper into disrepute”. A month later he was summoned to London for a disciplinary hearing, with the company secretary Tony Briscoe acting as prosecution counsel and Bagley sitting as judge.

Briscoe told MacKinnon the question he’d put to the RMT official “feels more like something a Daily Mail reporter would ask than someone from the Morning Star. You should have known better. This indicates a lack of journalistic etiquette and has damaged our relationship with the trade union movement.” The public had “no right to know” about whatever occurred between Hedley and Leneghan.

Stalinist leaving present
Bagley agreed. “After three years at the paper,” he said in his judgment against MacKinnon, “you should reasonably be expected to be familiar with the paper’s news priorities, which do not include reporting internal union rows or personal controversy. Your actions suggest a fundamental failure to grasp the Morning Star’s news focus, and by extension the role of any journalist employed by it.”

Having belatedly grasped the paper’s “focus” after being put on a final written warning for behaving like a journalist, MacKinnon handed in his notice last month and left on 8 August, writing a post on his blog explaining why he had resigned. That same day he received a magnificent Stalinist leaving present: a letter from Bob Oram, chair of the Morning Star’s management committee and senior organiser for, er, the RMT union.

“You are formally under investigation for an allegation of gross misconduct,” Oram wrote. “I recognise that you are in your final day of employment and will not be available for interview, but…” The accusations were a “gross breach of trust and confidence” and “bringing the Morning Star into disrepute”. Has it ever occurred to Oram and the other men who run the paper to charge themselves with the same offence?

More top stories in the latest issue:

Proven mis-sellers are among those lining up to pounce on cash-rich pensioners next year, all thanks to George Osborne’s new annuity rules.

Defence IT programmes have been a monumental disaster… so why are discredited contractors in line for yet more business from the MoD?

The British embassy in Stockholm seeks an intern to work on UK science projects – but only if he or she can find a sponsor. Perhaps Beijing or Moscow could stump up?

If the PM is so keen to crack ‘the walls of corporate secrecy’, why does his planned company register ignore trusts, favoured tool of the funny money brigade?

Big question marks hang over the future of social housing as think tank policy wonks vie to help the Tories dream up Right to Buy Mk II.

The former Tory housing minister now moonlighting for a private landlord who wants to build flats for renters (but not social housing tenants).

To read all these stories in full, you can buy the latest edition of Private Eye - or subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale:
2nd September 2014.
More From This Issue
more »
Top Stories
more »
All the latest gaffes
more »
Also Available Online
More From This Issue
Private Eye Issue 1373
private eye Only In The Magazine

‘No Boots on Ground’ as Army No Longer Has Functioning Boots… David Caesar Welcome Brutus Johnsonius Back to His Team… Seventeen Ways Mainstream Media Misrepresent BuzzFeed as a List Site… ‘We’re Bitter Together’ – Best Jokes from Scotland’s Festival of Fun… Fruity A Level Girls Jump 10% Less High on Front Pages than Previous Years… That Denis MacShame Prison Diary in Full.

And also...

- Stat attack: BBC’s statistics expert forced to backtrack over Gaza casualty statistics
- SuicideWatch: Editor’s code torn up as papers report the death of Robin Williams
- Doom & loom: From harmless craze to cancer warnings: how the Mail went potty
For all these stories you can buy the magazine or subscribe here and get delivery direct to your home every fortnight.
Next issue on sale: 2nd September 2014.

Private Eye Issue 1372